Reportationes

"There are also questions about the order in which he commented on the 'Sentences'. One plausible view is that he commented sequentially on all four books in the academic year 1302-03, being interrupted near the end by his exile from Paris, and resuming with book 4 upon his return in the spring of 1304. There are future-tense references in Book 4 to topics he will treat in Book 3, presumably in the academic year 1304/05, when he may have given another complete course of lectures on the 'Sentences'" [Williams (2003), 10].

'Reportationes' der Sentenzenvorlesungen des Duns Scotus in Paris.

Auguste Pelzer "proved the 'reported Paris lecture' existed in at least five different forms, and that instead of 'the great report examined by Duns Scotus' Wadding had published a 'mélange contaminé' based on the abbreviated version of William of Alnwick and the Paris edition of John Mair (Major) of 1517-18" [Wolter (1993), 15; er bezieht sich auf die Ergebnisse der Untersuchungen Pelzers (1923)].

Die Editoren der editio Vaticana unterscheiden folgende Fassungen der 'Reportata':

Sent. I:

● Reportatio I A ('Reportatio examinata'). Es handelt sich um von Scotus persönlich nachgeprüfte 'Reportata' seiner Pariser Vorlesungen über das I. Buch der Sentenzen. "Gesichert ist, dass Scotus eine Nachschrift seiner Pariser Vorlesungen zum ersten Buch der Sentenzen selbst überprüft hat. Sie wird als 'Reportatio examinata' (Rep. I A) bezeichnet." [Dreyer (2003), 10].

Ms.: Wien 1453 (entdeckt von Longpré): "Explicit Reportatio super primum Sententiarum, sub magistro Ioanne Scoto, et examinata cum eodem venerando doctore" (f. 125 va).

kritische Ed.: Johannes Duns Scotus: Reportatio Parisiensis examinata I 38-44. Pariser Vorlesung über Wissen und Kontingenz, hrsg., übers. u. eingel. v. Johannes R. Söder, Freiburg i. B. 2005 [Herders Bibliothek der Philosophie des Mittelalters, Band 4].

"The one clear fact is that Scotus himself personally examined a 'reportatio' of his lectures on Book I, which is therefore known as the 'Reportatio examinata'. Since this work represents Scotus's most mature commentary on the matters treated in 'Sentences' I, it is of paramount importance in understanding his thought and its development. Unfortunately, it has not yet been edited. What the Wadding edition prints as 'Reportatio' I is actually the Book I of the 'Additiones magnae'" [Williams (2003), 10]

"It is the source of many of the 'interpolated Texts' found in the first six volumes of the Vatican edition devoted to Book I of the 'Ordinatio'" [Wolter (1993), 14].

● Reportatio I B (ediert Paris 1517)

● Reportatio I C (von manchem mit einer 'Reportatio Cantabrigiensis' identifiziert) (noch nicht ediert)

● Reportatio I D (noch nicht ediert)

● Reportatio I E (noch nicht ediert) ["... is thought by many to be an amalgam of Henry Harclay's lectures and Scotus's own work. But see Balic [Balic (1939-1951), II (1941), 4-9]" [Williams (2003), 14, Anm. 34].

Sent. II:

● Reportatio II A (ed. von L. Wadding, II)

● Reportatio II B: eine kürzere Fassung, Grundquelle für die 'Additiones' 2 (noch nicht ediert)

Sent. III:

● Reportatio III A (ed. von L. Wadding, II)

● Reportatio III B (noch nicht ediert)

● Reportatio III C (noch nicht ediert)

● Reportatio III D (noch nicht ediert)

Sent. IV:

●'Reportatio IV A: (ed. von L. Wadding)

● Reportatio IV B (ed. Paris 1518).

Rodler deutet anhand seiner Edition des Prologes im Sinne der "Annahme verschiedener Reportationen einer Pariser Vorlesung" [mit Pelzer und Pelster (2005), 27*].

zu neueren Forschungsbeiträgen vgl. die Angaben zu den einzelnen Reportationen.

• Balic, Carl, Ratio criticae editionis Operum omnium I. D. Scoti. Rom (Schola typographica 'Pio X') 1939-1951 (3 Bde).
• Dreyer, M. / Ingham, Mary Beth: Johannes Duns Scotus zur Einführung, Hamburg (Junius) 2003.
• Pelzer, Auguste: "Le premier livre des Reportata Parisiensia", in: Annales de l'Institut supérieur de Philosophie 5 (1923), 449-491.
• Rodler, Klaus: Die Prologe der Reportata Parisiensia des Johannes Duns Scotus. Untersuchungen zur Textüberlieferung und kritische Edition, Innsbruck 2005 [Mediaevalia Oenipontana, 2].
• Williams, Thomas, "Introduction. The Life and Works of John Duns the Scot", in: Th. Williams (Hg.), The Cambridge Companion to Duns Scotus, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 2003, 1-14.
• Wolter, Allan B.: "Reflections on the Life and Works of Scotus", in: American Catholic Philosophical Quartely 67 (1993), 1-36.